Skip to content
SHIGLEYAcquisitions

We buy · Silver · By appointment only

We buy silver of every kind, sorted and valued in person.

Silver collections tend to be mixed: a few bars, a roll of old dimes, a box of .925 jewelry. We sort it with you by type and fineness, weigh it in view and explain how each group is valued against the day's silver market.

What we look at

What we buy: silver

Not sure whether something belongs on this list? Book an appointment and bring it along. Every item is evaluated in person.

  • .999 silver bars and rounds
  • American Silver Eagles and world silver coins
  • Pre-1965 dimes, quarters and halves
  • Silver dollars
  • .925 jewelry
  • Coin silver
  • Scrap and broken silver
  • Silver medals and ingots

How we evaluate it, in person

I

Sorted by fineness

Fine silver, sterling and coin silver are separated and valued correctly.

II

Market based

Offers follow the silver market at the time of your appointment.

III

Coins checked

Silver coins are reviewed for collector value before being treated as metal.

Your appointment

What to expect at your appointment

Appointments are held at our Overland Park office, Monday to Friday between 9am and 5pm. We evaluate every item in person.

  1. IA private room and your full attention, with no one waiting behind you.
  2. IIEach item tested and weighed in front of you, using methods that don't damage it.
  3. IIIA plain explanation of what you have before any number is mentioned.
  4. IVAn itemized offer. Accept all of it, part of it, or none of it.

What to bring

01

A photo ID

A valid government-issued photo ID is needed to complete any sale.

02

The items themselves

Bring them as they are. No cleaning, polishing or sorting needed.

03

Any paperwork you have

Receipts, appraisals, certificates, grading slabs, boxes and papers. Helpful, never required.

Good to know

Questions about selling silver

Do you buy silver plate?

Silver plate has very little metal value, so we usually can't make an offer on it. We'll gladly sort it out from your solid silver so you know what you have.

Should I polish my silver first?

No. Tarnish doesn't change silver's value, and polishing collectible coins can lower it.

How large a silver collection can you handle?

Any size. Let us know roughly how much you have when you book so we can set aside enough time.

Discreet and confidential

A quiet, professional setting for a personal decision.

  • Private appointments

    One client at a time, by appointment only. No storefront, no audience.

  • Confidential

    What you bring and what you decide stays between us. We never share your details for marketing.

  • Evaluated in person

    No guesses over the phone. Every item is examined in hand before any offer.

  • No pressure

    You can say no, or take time to think. There is never an obligation to sell.

Private appointments

Book an appointment to sell silver

Request a time that suits you and tell us roughly what you plan to bring. We evaluate every item in person, privately and confidentially, at your appointment.

By appointment onlyMonday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Closed Saturday and Sunday.
Call to book (402) 650-5981
What you'd like to sell * (choose any)
Private and confidential. We evaluate every item in person by appointment and don't price items over the phone or online. Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm.